Guillaume Bonnissent’s Insurance Technology Diary

Episode 103: CRM brûlée

I had a really interesting conversation with a client about CRMs.

That might be the most unlikely sentence I’ve ever written in my Diary, but stick with me on this one.

The client showed me the draft of a technology architecture diagram for his firm. One of the boxes next to Quotech was labelled “CRM?”

Customer Relationship Management used to refer to a combination of sales strategies and processes used by businesses to manage and improve their interactions with current and potential clients.

Now it’s just software (think Hubspot, Salesforce, MS Dynamics).

The little box made me think of the specificities of the specialty insurance industry, and why it requires people with expertise in the sector to design software that allows practitioners to be more effective and efficient at their job.

We have, for example, to deal with broker hierarchies, not to mention the complexity of the interconnected relationships between retail agents, syndicates, MGAs, cedents, insureds, carriers, and sometimes even end-consumers. It’s more of a web than a chain.

That tangle of links makes insurance-relationship workflows perplexingly complicated. Compared to the sales pipelines companies in most sectors have to deal with, the speciality insurance funnel can resemble the manifold of a twelve-room underfloor heating system, multiplied by multi-layered risk placements, multi-carrier syndication, and multi-centred quote-to-bind-to-issue cycles.

Meanwhile our platforms must track a boggling multiplicity of details. Even setting aside risk data, they must record and apply binding authority limits, account in in a variety of international currencies, and calculate complex commission splits, to name just three. Knowing what applies to whom is fraught with peril.

That means an underwriter intending to adopt a standard CRM (the kind that a company like Quotech would use) faces a calamity of challenge. At the very least, the system would need modifications to make note of:

  • the insureds, both prospective and existing. That’s not as easily done as said, however, since underwriters tend to have no direct relationship with their insureds. Most of the time, brokers control that relationship (and therefore the cash flow).
  • Perhaps in addition we need to modify for BRM, or broker relationship management. We should create a sub-platform to deal with our interactions both with active and with prospective intermediaries. A single broker relationship may of course involve many, many individuals across multiple departments, classes, lines of business, or locations. Each of those is complicated by their involvement in not just one deal, but inn several (provided, of course, that they present more than one submission over time). The BRM will be intricate, to say the least.
  • We need also to modify the basis on which the importance of deals under relationships are judged. Usually in CRMs this is a monetary value. For an MGA, should it simply be gross written premium? That’s the easiest, but net written premium is seemingly a very much more adequate measure of importance. Perhaps, though, net earned premium is most relevant day to day, or underwriting profit. But are we married to a currency value? I could make a strong argument for loss ratio.
  • Obviously each of those figures will have to be modified by attributable investment return on the premium, and adjusted according to any IBNR that has not yet been fully earned. Which brings us to the question of how we judge a deal within the CRM at a portfolio level, with quantifications of the number of submissions received, the conversion rate, payment terms and delays… I could think of more. Perhaps it needs to draw on the exposure management system.

Basically, an off-the-shelf CRM will need rather a lot of tweaking before it is able to incorporate all the relevant data available in the adjacent underwriting platform (assuming your workbench is already of sufficient quality to contain and make accessible all the relevant data). Without tweaks which in practice will equate to a complete rebuild, the challenge is to ram a quadrilateral peg into a mundanely round hole. It’s not going to work.

It’s often said that ours is a relationship business, and that people cannot be replaced by machines. Even as a vendor, I couldn’t agree more. Cuthbert Heath didn’t have a CRM, at least not in the software sense. He had nothing more than an excellent reputation for assuming risk and paying claims, the brilliant idea of going to California to sell aftershock insurance right after a huge earthquake, and a very well-organised diary.

When it comes to managing the combination of sales strategies and processes used by businesses to manage and improve their interactions with current and potential clients in the speciality insurance sector, the personal touch trumps technology. A handful of algorithms won’t cut it. My own off-the-shelf CRM hasn’t landed a single deal yet. The question mark on my client’s tech map should not be erased in haste.  

Guillaume Bonnissent is CEO of Quotech.